Global Academic Publishers Logo
GAP Insights · Publishing Guides · 2026

How to Become a Journal Editor: Roles, Steps and Tips

By Muaz Dave · 9 November 2026, 7:12 AM PKT

How to Become a Journal Editor: Roles, Steps and Tips

Introduction

It is Tuesday morning, and Dr. Sana Malik, associate editor of a veterinary journal, opens her inbox to 14 new manuscripts, three reviewer reports that arrived overnight, and an author asking why a decision is two weeks late. Before lunch she will screen four new submissions, invite six reviewers, and write two decision letters. This is the editor's working week — not a ceremonial title, but a steady flow of judgement calls, emails, and deadlines that sit on top of a full academic job.

This guide shows how to become a journal editor through the route most editors actually take: what the job looks like day to day, which roles exist, how appointments are made, and the concrete steps — reviewing, board service, a guest-edited issue, a short letter — that put your name in front of the people who appoint editors.

A Week in the Life of an Editor

An editor's week is built around manuscripts in motion. On Monday, Sana screens new submissions: does each paper fit the journal's scope, follow its format, and clear basic checks on ethics and originality? Papers that fail are returned the same day with a short note. Papers that pass go to reviewers. On Wednesday she reads the reports that came back, weighs them, and writes decisions. On Friday she chases late reviewers and updates the journal's tracker so nothing sits unanswered for a month.

The volume surprises most new editors. An associate editor for a mid-sized journal may handle 60 to 80 manuscripts a year, which means two or three active decisions every week. The work is never finished in a single sitting: a manuscript moves through screening, review, revision, and decision over weeks, and the editor carries a mental list of where each one stands. A simple tracker — a spreadsheet with one row per manuscript, the date it arrived, the reviewers invited, and the next action — is the tool that keeps this manageable.

The Five Editorial Roles, and Which One Fits You First

The editor-in-chief leads the journal, sets its direction, and takes responsibility for its quality. Associate editors handle manuscripts in their own subject areas and make decisions or recommendations on individual papers. Section editors manage one article type, such as case reports or reviews, and guest editors run a single special issue from proposal to publication.

The fifth role, editorial board member, advises on policy and reviews papers but does not make decisions. This is the natural first step: board membership is offered to reliable reviewers, it puts your name on the journal's masthead, and it lets you learn how decisions are made before you have to make them. Aim for board membership first, associate editor second, and editor-in-chief only after years in the role. A researcher who asks to be editor-in-chief with no board or reviewing record is asking for a job they have not yet earned.

Who Appoints Editors, and What They Look For

Editors are appointed by the journal's owner — a publisher, a learned society, or a university — usually on the recommendation of the current editor-in-chief, and usually for a fixed term of three to five years. The appointment panel reads a short record: your publications in the field, your reviewing history, your service, and your vision for the journal. They are not counting papers alone. They are asking whether you can judge other people's work fairly and on time.

Three things carry the most weight. First, a publication record that shows you know the field, not only your own narrow topic. Second, a reviewing record the journal can check — editors remember reviewers who return reports in two weeks and write reports that help the author. Third, breadth: an editor must judge papers across a whole subject area, so a record of conference organisation, society work, or a special issue shows you think beyond your own research. If your record shows only your own papers, you are not yet ready.

Step 1: Become the Reviewer Editors Remember

Every editor starts as a reviewer, and the path begins with accepting invitations in your area and returning reports on time. Aim for about one review a month — twelve a year — for the journals you would like to edit. A report that arrives in ten days, summarises the paper in three lines, lists three strengths, and gives five numbered points the author can act on will be remembered. A report that arrives six weeks late with two vague sentences will also be remembered, for the wrong reason.

Consider Dr. Bilal Ahmed, a lecturer in animal nutrition. In his first year after his PhD he reviewed nine papers for three journals, always within the deadline. When one journal needed a new board member, the editor-in-chief looked at the reviewer list and Bilal's name came up because his reports were prompt and useful. Two years later, the same editor invited him to guest-edit a special issue on feed additives. Reviewing is not a chore on the way to editing; it is the interview for the job, conducted over years.

Step 2: Take a Visible Service Role

After a year of steady reviewing, take a role people can see. The strongest move is proposing a special issue. Write to the editor-in-chief with a one-page proposal: a title, four or five sentences on why the topic matters now, a list of six researchers you would invite, and a timetable — call for papers in March, reviews by July, publication in December. A proposal that names real contributors and real dates shows you can run a journal, not only review for one.

Other visible roles count too. Join an editorial board when invited, review for a society journal, organise a conference session, or serve on your university's research ethics committee. Each role puts your name in front of appointment panels, and together they form the service record an appointment panel reads. Keep a simple log: the journal, the role, the dates, and one line on what you did. When you apply, you will need those details, and you will not remember them without the log.

Step 3: Write the Expression of Interest

Editorial vacancies are advertised on publisher websites, society newsletters, and academic job boards, and they are sometimes filled by invitation. When you apply, send a short statement — one page, not five — explaining why you want the role, what you would bring, and your vision for the journal. Attach your publication list, your reviewing record, and any editing or board experience.

A strong letter sounds like this: "Dear Professor Rahman, I am writing to express interest in the associate editor post for animal nutrition. I have published 14 papers in this area, reviewed 26 manuscripts for your journal in the past three years, and guest-edited the 2024 special issue on feed additives, which published 11 papers. I would like to shorten review times in my section by building a pool of 40 reviewers and replying to authors within a week of submission." It is specific, it names numbers the journal can check, and it offers a plan. A weak letter says only that the writer loves the journal. Tailor every letter to the journal: show that you read it and have ideas for its future.

Your First 90 Days as an Associate Editor

Do not change anything in the first month. Read the journal's policies on scope, peer review, ethics, and open access, and meet the publisher's staff who support you. Ask the editor-in-chief how decisions are usually worded and which reviewers are reliable. Handle manuscripts steadily rather than in bursts, and keep a note of every decision and its reason.

In the second month, build your reviewer pool: a list of 30 to 40 reliable reviewers in your area, with their subjects and their usual response time. Thank each reviewer promptly when a report arrives — a short email keeps good reviewers willing. In the third month, review your own record: how many manuscripts did you handle, how long did decisions take, and where did you get stuck? By day 90 you should know the journal's rhythm, have a pool you trust, and have a clear sense of what you would improve next.

Handling the Three Hardest Decisions

The first hard decision is a split review. When reviewers disagree, look at the evidence each one gives, consider a third review, and write a decision that explains the disagreement honestly. The author may not like the outcome, but a letter that quotes the key concern and suggests a way forward is respected even when it rejects.

The second is an appeal. An author who appeals a rejection deserves a fresh look, not a defensive reply. Check whether a clear error occurred — a reviewer who judged the wrong version, a factual mistake in the report — and if so, say so and reconsider. If no error occurred, explain the outcome briefly and close the matter. The third is an ethics case: suspected plagiarism, duplicate submission, or an undisclosed conflict. Follow the journal's policy and the guidance of the Committee on Publication Ethics, keep a written record of every step, and never decide an ethics case alone — consult the editor-in-chief and the publisher.

Five Mistakes New Editors Make

The first mistake is taking too long: manuscripts pile up, authors grow anxious, and reviewers lose interest. Set a weekly routine and stick to it. The second is accepting every paper the reviewers liked without checking scope, originality, or ethics yourself — the editor's judgement is the last check, not a rubber stamp. The third is writing decision letters that are vague or harsh, which tell the author nothing and damage the journal's reputation.

The fourth is choosing reviewers from too narrow a circle — the same five names for every paper — which slows decisions and narrows the journal's view. Build a broad pool and record who reviewed what. The fifth is changing the journal's direction before understanding it: new editors who arrive with big plans and no knowledge of the journal's policies usually create confusion. Learn the journal first, change it second. Our guide to double-blind peer review explained shows the process from the reviewer's side as well, which helps new editors see what their decisions feel like to receive.

Is Editing Right for You? A Five-Question Check

Answer these five questions honestly. Do you enjoy reading widely, even papers outside your own topic? Can you make a careful decision and explain it to someone who will dislike it? Are you willing to spend three to four hours a week on work that few people will see? Can you stay fair when an author you know submits a weak paper? And can you keep going when the inbox never empties?

If you answered yes to four or five, editing will suit you, and the next step is simple: review regularly, do it well, and let editors know you are willing to serve. Offer to guest-edit a special issue, join a board, and build the record that leads to an appointment. If you answered no to three or more, the role will frustrate you — and that is useful to know before you accept it. Editing is service to a field, and the scholars who do it well are the ones who wanted the work itself, not only the title.

Editorial Roles at a Glance

RoleMain taskTypical first step
Editor-in-ChiefLeads the journal and sets its directionYears as associate editor and board member
Associate EditorDecides on manuscripts in a subject areaReliable reviewing, then board membership
Section EditorManages one article type or topicEditing a special issue in that area
Guest EditorRuns a single special issueProposing a themed issue to the editor
Editorial Board MemberAdvises on policy and reviews papersRegular reviewing for the journal

Further Reading and Useful Resources

These authoritative external resources explain the standards and tools mentioned in this guide:

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I become a journal editor?
Start by becoming a reliable reviewer: accept invitations in your area, return reports on time, and write thorough, constructive reviews. Then take visible service roles, such as editing a special issue or joining an editorial board. Editors are usually appointed from reviewers and board members the journal already knows and trusts.

Do I need a PhD to become a journal editor?
Most editors hold a doctorate and have a strong publication record in the journal's field, but the exact requirements vary by journal. What matters most is subject expertise, reviewing experience, and a reputation for fair, timely decisions. Some practitioner and professional journals appoint editors with a master's degree and deep field experience.

Are journal editors paid?
Most academic journal editors are not paid a salary. Some receive a small honorarium, help with conference travel, or a reduction in publishing charges. The main rewards are professional: influence over the field, early sight of new research, a wider network, and recognition of academic leadership for promotion.

What is the difference between an editor-in-chief and an associate editor?
The editor-in-chief leads the whole journal, sets its direction, and takes responsibility for its quality and reputation. Associate editors handle manuscripts in their own subject areas and make decisions or recommendations on individual papers. Most editors begin as associate editors before becoming editor-in-chief.

How much time does editing take?
An associate editor typically spends several hours a week on the role, and an editor-in-chief spends more. The work includes screening submissions, choosing reviewers, reading reports, and writing decision letters. Protect a regular slot in your week, because manuscripts arrive continuously and delays frustrate authors and reviewers.

How do I handle a conflict of interest as an editor?
Do not handle a manuscript from a colleague, recent co-author, student, or anyone with whom you have a personal or financial interest. Pass it to another editor and record the decision. Declare your own conflicts to the publisher, protect the confidentiality of manuscripts under review, and follow the journal's ethics policies.

Submit your manuscript  ← Back to GAP Insights

More Resources for Researchers

Research Resources Directory

Useful publishers, databases, funders, tools and institutions for researchers:

Publishers

Databases and Indexes

Preprint Servers and Repositories

Ethics and Reporting Standards

Funders

Research Tools

Health and Veterinary Organisations

Veterinary Schools

Leading Universities

Major Journals