
When Sara, a PhD student in veterinary sciences, designed her first study — interviews with 40 dairy farmers about mastitis treatment — her supervisor asked one question before anything else: "Have you applied for ethics approval?" Sara had assumed approval was a formality, a single form to sign before the real work began. Three weeks later she understood: the committee wanted her full protocol, her exact interview questions, her consent form, and a written plan for storing the farmers' personal details. Her first application came back with eight queries.
This guide explains how to write an ethics application that survives first review: what the application is, who reads it, which documents you need, how to write each section, and the mistakes that send applications back. It covers writing and submitting the application itself. The consent form and the approval decision are covered in our companion guide on research ethics, consent and approval — the two guides belong together, but they are not the same job.
An ethics application is the written case you make to an ethics committee that your study is ethically acceptable: you have identified the risks, reduced them as far as possible, and shown the benefit justifies what remains. The committee judges what you wrote, not what you intended — if a safeguard is not written down, it cannot assume it exists.
Two confusions cause most trouble. First, the application is not the consent form — the form is one document inside the application, the paper a participant signs to show they understood the study and agreed to take part. Second, submitting an application is not a guarantee of approval: a committee can approve it, ask for changes, or reject it. A well-written application gives the committee everything it needs to decide.
If your study involves people, assume you need approval: interviews, surveys, experiments, observations, or the use of personal data and human samples. If it involves animals, an animal ethics committee reviews it instead, as our companion guide on research ethics, consent and approval explains.
Some studies genuinely do not need a full application — fully anonymised, publicly available data, for example, or a service evaluation in some institutions. But the line is thinner than most researchers think: a village name, a herd size, or a rare disease can identify a person when combined, and the committee, not the researcher, decides where the line falls.
Never decide this yourself, and never start collecting data first. Ask your committee in writing whether your study needs review, and keep the answer: data collected without required approval usually cannot be used, and many journals will refuse to publish it.
The committee has different names in different systems — an institutional review board (IRB) in the United States, a research ethics committee (REC) in the United Kingdom, an ethics review board (ERB) elsewhere — but the job is the same. In Pakistan, the National Bioethics Committee sets national guidance, and most universities run their own boards.
A committee is not a panel of your supervisors. It typically includes scientists from other fields, a non-scientist, and a lay member who reads the application as an ordinary person would; some add a statistician and a legal adviser. That mix is deliberate: if the lay member cannot follow your methods section, the application is not clear enough yet.
Review comes in three speeds. Full-board review is for higher-risk studies, decided at a committee meeting. Expedited or proportionate review is for low-risk studies, handled by a smaller group between meetings. Exempt review, under the US Common Rule, covers certain low-risk categories — but "exempt" is still a formal decision by the committee, not something you declare yourself.
An application is a package, not a single form:
One rule governs the whole package: every document must agree with every other. If the information sheet says recordings are kept for two years and the protocol says three, the committee will send the application back.
| Document | What it must show | Common mistake |
|---|---|---|
| Study protocol | Question, design, sample, analysis | Methods too vague to follow |
| Participant information sheet | Plain-language explanation of the study | Technical language from the protocol |
| Consent form | What participants agree to, and their right to withdraw | Different storage period from the information sheet |
| Questionnaire or interview guide | The exact questions you will ask | A summary instead of the real questions |
| Data management plan | Storage, access, encryption, retention | "On my laptop" with no encryption or backup |
| Training certificates | Ethics training completed by the team | Certificates expired or missing |
Application forms differ, but the sections are nearly always the same — write each one as if the reader knows nothing about your field.
Study summary and aims. One paragraph, in plain language: the question, why it matters, and what you will do. If you cannot state the aim in two sentences, the committee will struggle to judge it.
Methods. Enough detail for a non-specialist to follow: the design, the setting, the sample size and how you chose it. A reader from another department should be able to picture the study from this section alone — see our guide on how to write the methodology section.
Participants and recruitment. Who they are, how many, how you will approach them, and your inclusion and exclusion criteria. Children, patients, students, and employees need extra justification — they may find it harder to refuse.
Risks and benefits. Name every risk — physical, psychological, social, and data-related — and the safeguard for each one. Then state the benefit honestly: most studies benefit future patients or farmers, not the participants, and committees notice an overstated benefit.
Consent. How you will inform participants, record their agreement, and handle their right to withdraw — including what happens to their data if they withdraw. If some participants cannot consent for themselves, say who will consent on their behalf.
Confidentiality and data. Explain anonymisation versus pseudonymisation in your own case: will names ever appear in your files, and where is the link between codes and names kept? State where data will be stored, who can access it, whether it is encrypted, how long it will be kept, and what happens to it afterwards.
Funding and conflicts of interest. Declare them plainly: who funds the study, and whether any researcher has a financial interest in the outcome. A declared conflict is manageable; a discovered one is not.
The three samples below are written for fictional studies.
Sample 1 — the risk section of a farmer survey. "This study involves no physical procedures. The main risk is that a farmer could be identified from a combination of village, herd size, and disease history. To prevent this, results will be reported only in grouped form, village names will be removed from transcripts, and the file linking codes to names will be stored separately on an encrypted drive accessible only to the principal investigator. Recordings will be deleted once transcripts are checked, within three months of the interview."
Sample 2 — consent for cattle blood sampling. "Blood samples of 5 ml per animal will be taken by a registered veterinarian using standard aseptic technique. Written consent will be obtained from each farm owner before sampling, using the attached form, which explains the procedure, the small risk of brief discomfort or bruising, and that the owner may withdraw any animal at any time. The protocol has been reviewed by the institutional animal ethics committee."
Sample 3 — a participant information sheet for student interviews. "You are invited to take part in an interview study about laboratory safety training. The interview takes about 30 minutes. You may stop at any time and skip any question. Your name will not appear in any report — we will use a code instead. The recording will be stored on an encrypted drive and deleted after two years."
Students may find it hard to refuse a researcher from their own department, so stating plainly that they can stop, with no consequences, is the safeguard the committee looks for.
Timelines are the part of the process most often underestimated, and the easiest to check. In the United Kingdom, the Health Research Authority states that a research ethics committee should give its opinion within 60 days of a valid application, and low-risk studies can use proportionate review, which is designed to be quicker. In the United States, timelines vary by institution, and full-board review commonly takes several weeks, because committees usually meet monthly — missing one deadline can add a month.
The practical rule is simple: submit at least eight to twelve weeks before you need to start collecting data, check the committee's meeting dates and deadlines first, and budget for one round of queries. The framework behind these timelines is the Declaration of Helsinki, first adopted by the World Medical Association in 1964 and revised in 2024; the US Common Rule, revised in 2018; and the CIOMS guidelines of 2016.
Committees return applications for a small set of predictable reasons. Most of them are avoidable:
When an application comes back, answer every query in writing, point by point, and highlight each change so the reviewer can find it without hunting. Our guide on how to respond to peer reviewer comments uses the same point-by-point discipline.
Queries are normal, not a rejection: most applications need one round of changes. If you disagree, say so respectfully and give your reason with evidence — committees accept reasoned disagreement; they do not accept silence.
Approval has conditions. Any change to your methods, sample, or documents needs a formal amendment approved before you implement it — do not change the study first and report it later. Most approvals also require progress or annual reports and a final report, and approval has an expiry date. Adverse events must be reported promptly under the committee's own rules.
Run through this list on the final version, not on a draft:
These authoritative external resources explain the standards and guidance mentioned in this guide:
Do I need ethics approval for a survey that collects no personal data?
Probably not, but do not decide this yourself. Many committees still want a short notification or a formal exemption decision, and the line between anonymous and identifiable data is thinner than most researchers think. Ask your committee in writing before you collect anything; a written exemption protects you if the question comes up later.
How long does ethics approval take?
It depends on the committee and the risk level. In the UK, a research ethics committee should give its opinion within 60 days of a valid application, and low-risk studies can use faster proportionate review. Allow eight to twelve weeks before your planned start date, and check your committee's meeting dates — missing one deadline can add a month.
What is the difference between an ethics application and a consent form?
The application is the whole case you put to the committee: your protocol, methods, risks, and safeguards. The consent form is one document inside it — the form a participant signs to show they understood the study and agreed to take part. Approval of the application does not replace consent, and a signed consent form does not replace approval.
Can I start collecting data while my application is under review?
No. Data collected before approval usually cannot be used, and many journals will refuse to publish a study that began without it. If your start date is fixed, tell the committee early and ask about proportionate or expedited review instead of collecting data first. Waiting is frustrating, but using unapproved data is far worse.
What happens if the committee asks for changes?
You receive a list of queries, usually with a deadline for reply. Answer each one in writing, point by point, and highlight the changes in your revised documents so the reviewers can find them. Most applications need one round of changes; that is normal. Only a small number are rejected outright — usually when the study design is unsafe.
Do animal studies need ethics approval too?
Yes. Animal studies are reviewed by an animal ethics committee, which applies the 3Rs: replace animals where possible, reduce the number used, and refine procedures to minimise suffering. Your application must justify the species, the number of animals, the procedures, and the housing. Owner consent is also needed when animals belong to farmers or private owners.
Submit your manuscript ← Back to GAP Insights
Useful publishers, databases, funders, tools and institutions for researchers: