
Dr. Sana Iqbal waited three months for a decision on her mastitis study of 48 dairy farms around Faisalabad. The rejection quoted a reviewer who said the study "did not include a control group" — yet Table 2, on page 6, reports a control group of 40 animals. The reviewer had simply missed it.
Her first instinct was to send the paper elsewhere — the right move in most rejections. But this decision rested on a clear factual error, and that is exactly what a journal appeal is for.
An appeal is a short, formal letter asking the editor to reconsider because something specific went wrong — not a second submission, a complaint, or a negotiation. And the honest truth first: appeals rarely succeed.
An appeal is a formal written request to the editor — usually the editor-in-chief — asking for a rejection decision to be reconsidered. You are not submitting a new version, and you are not asking reviewers to change their minds. You are asking the editor to look again at the decision itself, because a specific error affected it.
Most journals describe their appeals process in their author guidelines, and the decision letter often says whether an appeal is possible. Some state plainly that decisions are final — then there is no appeal to make.
The appeal is a letter, usually one page. It names the manuscript by ID and title, states the exact point in dispute, and gives the evidence — a page, a table, a quoted sentence. The editor then decides, often after consulting the original reviewers or a new one. That decision is final.
Authors mix up three different actions. An appeal asks the same journal to reconsider the same manuscript because of a specific error. A resubmission sends the manuscript — usually revised — to a different journal. Resubmission is the normal route after a rejection. See our guide on how to handle a journal rejection and resubmit.
A desk rejection means the editor rejected the paper before peer review, usually over scope. You can appeal it, but it is even harder to win, because the decision was the editor's own judgement about fit — not a reviewer's mistake. If your paper was desk rejected, read our guide on how to handle a desk rejection first.
Withdrawing is different again: you pull the paper yourself while it is still under consideration, and you need the editor's confirmation before submitting elsewhere. See our guide on how to withdraw a manuscript from a journal.
An appeal has a chance only on a small number of grounds. If your case matches one, appeal. If it matches none, revise and submit elsewhere.
First, a clear factual error by a reviewer or editor — the strongest ground. Dr. Iqbal's case is the textbook example: the reviewer said there was no control group, and the manuscript plainly had one. Other versions: a reviewer says a method was not used when the Methods section describes it. The test is simple: can you point to a page, line, or table that proves the statement wrong?
Second, reviewers who directly contradict each other on the same point. Reviewer 1 demands a larger sample "to support the conclusion", while Reviewer 2 demands a smaller one — and the editor's letter cites both as reasons to reject. The author cannot satisfy both at once. Pointing that out, calmly and with quotations, is a legitimate appeal.
Third, a procedural mistake. This is rarer, but it happens: a reviewer with a clear conflict of interest was used, the decision letter quotes a report written about a different manuscript, or a promised re-review never happened. Editors take procedural mistakes seriously — but you need evidence, not suspicion.
Fourth, a decision that contradicts the journal's own stated policy. If the guidelines say the journal publishes pilot studies, and the rejection says they are out of scope, quote the policy and the letter side by side. This ground is narrow: it works only when the contradiction is direct and written down.
Notice what is missing: "I disagree with the reviewers." Disagreement alone is not a ground. An appeal argues the process went wrong, not that it was harsh.
Most rejections belong here, not in the last section. Being honest about which side your paper falls on is the hardest part.
Do not appeal because the decision feels unfair. A researcher spent two years on a study of feed additives, and the topic genuinely matters for small dairy farmers — yet the reviewers found the sample too small to support the central claim. Effort and importance do not override a methodological weakness.
Do not appeal when the reviewers found a real weakness. If they are right that the sample is small or the methods unclear, fix the weakness and submit the improved paper elsewhere. Appealing a correct criticism wastes the editor's time.
Do not appeal an out-of-scope decision. Scope is the editor's judgement about what the journal publishes. A paper on poultry nutrition sent to a journal that publishes mainly large-animal clinical work was simply sent to the wrong home.
Finally, do not appeal to "try your luck". An appeal with no specific error reads as a request for a second opinion, which journals do not give. A baseless appeal can mark you as a difficult author.
No journal publishes an appeal success rate, so there is no honest percentage to quote. What the published guidance says, consistently, is that appeals succeed only in a small minority of cases, and almost always because the appeal showed a concrete error.
The Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) advises journals to have a clear, published appeals process. Nature's author guidance says a decision is overturned only when the appeal shows a specific error or new evidence. The BMJ's guidance says much the same.
Treat an appeal as a long shot with a specific trigger, not a second chance. If the trigger is real, appeal well; if not, revise and submit elsewhere.
Step 1: Read the decision letter twice and find the exact sentence you are disputing. An appeal that argues against a general impression fails; one that answers a specific sentence can succeed. If you cannot find a sentence to dispute, you probably do not have an appeal.
Step 2: Check the appeals policy and the deadline in the author guidelines and the decision letter. Find the right recipient, usually the editor-in-chief. Many journals set a window of a few weeks, so do not wait a month to start.
Step 3: Gather the evidence. For each point, note the exact reviewer quotation and the exact place in your manuscript that answers it: page, section, table, or line number. A claim without a location is an opinion; with a page number, it is evidence.
Step 4: Write one page. Open politely and name the manuscript by ID, title, and decision date. State the specific error in one short paragraph, give the evidence in a second, and close by asking the editor to reconsider — if appropriate, with a fresh review of the disputed point. Keep it under about 500 words: a long letter is skimmed.
Step 5: Have a colleague read it first and ask: does this sound calm and factual, or angry and defensive? If they hesitate, rewrite. Then send it and wait — do not send a second appeal, and do not chase the editor while it is being considered.
Here is a letter based on Dr. Iqbal's case. It names one error, gives the evidence, and asks for one thing. Replace the bracketed details with your own.
Dear Dr. [Editor-in-Chief's name],
I am writing to appeal the decision on manuscript [ID], "[Title]", rejected on [date]. I respect the reviewers' time and the editorial decision, and I am appealing on one specific point.
Reviewer 2 states that the study "did not include a control group". The manuscript does include one: Table 2 (page 6) reports a control group of 40 animals, and the Methods section (page 4) describes how it was selected and managed. I believe this point affected the recommendation, and I would be grateful if you could reconsider the decision, if appropriate with a fresh review of this point.
Thank you for considering this appeal.
Yours sincerely,
Dr. [Your name]
Notice what the letter does not do: it does not summarise the paper or criticise the reviewer. It asks the editor to check one fact. That restraint is what makes it credible.
The editor-in-chief, or a senior editor not involved in the original decision, reads the appeal first. They may consult the original reviewers or invite a new one. Expect to wait two to six weeks — appeals are handled alongside new submissions, not ahead of them.
Three outcomes are possible: the appeal is upheld and the paper goes back for review; it is rejected and the original decision stands — the most common outcome; or the editor offers resubmission as a new manuscript. Either way, the appeal decision is final.
First, use the reviewer comments anyway. The next journal's reviewers will often raise the same points — fixing them now saves a second rejection. See our guide on how to respond to peer reviewer comments.
Second, choose a better-fitting journal: a specialist journal instead of a general one, or one that regularly publishes studies of your size and type. See our guides on why papers are rejected and handling a rejection. Third, update the cover letter and reformat for the new journal — never send the same file unchanged.
| Situation | What to do | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Reviewer made a factual error | Appeal | Evidence can prove the error |
| Reviewers contradict each other | Appeal | Both demands cannot be met at once |
| Procedural mistake by the journal | Appeal | The process itself went wrong |
| You disagree with the judgement | Move on | Judgement is the editor's to make |
| Reviewers found a real weakness | Fix it, then move on | The criticism is correct |
| Paper was out of scope | Move on | Scope is the editor's decision |
Most failed appeals fail for avoidable reasons. Do not write a long letter — editors skim long appeals. Do not attack the reviewers; a letter that calls a reviewer incompetent reads as a complaint about a person, not evidence. Do not quote your whole paper back; one page number beats three paragraphs of summary. Do not appeal twice, and do not threaten to complain publicly.
Two mistakes are easy to miss. First, sending the appeal to the wrong person — a handling editor who has already decided, or an inbox nobody monitors. Second, missing the deadline: many journals set a window of a few weeks, and a late appeal is refused on timing alone. Check both before you write a word.
Run through this list on the final letter, not a draft:
If every box is ticked, send the appeal and wait. If even one is not, fix it first — or revise and submit elsewhere.
These authoritative external resources explain the standards and processes mentioned in this guide:
How long do I have to appeal a journal rejection?
Check the decision letter and the journal's author guidelines first — many journals set a window of a few weeks from the decision date, and a late appeal is refused on timing alone. Do not wait a month to decide. If no deadline is stated, send the appeal within two to three weeks, while the decision is still fresh.
Can I appeal a desk rejection?
Yes, but it is harder to win than an appeal after peer review. A desk rejection is the editor's judgement about scope, not a reviewer's mistake, so there is usually no factual error to point to. Appeal only if the decision contradicts the journal's stated policy — for example, it publishes pilot studies, then rejects yours as out of scope.
Will appealing hurt my chances with the journal later?
A single polite, evidence-based appeal will not harm you; editors expect them and handle them routinely. What damages your standing is a long, angry, or baseless appeal, repeated appeals, or public complaints about the journal. Keep the letter short, factual, and courteous, and the editor will judge the paper, not the person.
Should I include new data in my appeal?
No. An appeal asks the editor to reconsider the decision on the manuscript as submitted, not to judge a new version. New data belongs in a revised manuscript submitted to another journal, or in a resubmission if the editor invites one. Mentioning new results in an appeal letter only muddies the one point you are asking the editor to check.
What if the editor does not reply to my appeal?
Wait at least four to six weeks before following up once, politely, because appeals are handled alongside new submissions. If there is still no reply after a further two weeks, treat the original decision as standing and move on. Do not send repeated emails — chasing an appeal does not speed it up and can irritate the editor handling it.
Can I submit the same paper elsewhere while appealing?
No. While an appeal is pending, the manuscript is still considered to be with the first journal. Submitting it to a second journal at the same time risks duplicate submission, which can lead to rejection by both journals. Wait for the appeal outcome, and only submit elsewhere once the appeal is decided or the paper is formally withdrawn.
Submit your manuscript ← Back to GAP Insights
Useful publishers, databases, funders, tools and institutions for researchers: